I was listening to Colin Cowherd on the radio this morning. He hosts a sports-radio talk show every morning from 7 am – 10 am. Today Colin talked a lot about Carmelo Anthony ( one of the star players for the Knicks ), and also about the resignation of their head coach Mike D’Antoni.
While I listened to the show, a man called into the radio station claiming he works for the New York Knicks. This man told the listening audience that he reviews game film for the Knicks. The man made the comment that Carmelo Anthony and Amare Stoudemire rarely play defense, or are often in the wrong position on the floor defensively.
I was curious, because I had heard this claim many times before, and wanted to investigate it further. So I went on YouTube and found some recent footage of the Knicks vs the 76ers. After watching just a single clip, I have to agree with the caller. But in fairness, Melo and Amare are not the only ones that don’t play good defense. Jeremy Lin and other members of the team need help as well.
Below is a video clip of the Knicks vs the 76ers on March 11, 2012. Please stop the film at all the times below, read my comments, then watch each particular segment over and over again to understand what I mean.
As you will see, just because players can score in the 20′s or 30′s each game, does NOT mean they are GREAT basketball players. A GREAT basketball player plays BOTH ends of the floor:
.16 seconds – .27 seconds
Carmelo throws the ball away ( which happens to every player at some point ), but watch his reaction. The mistake Carmelo made was not turning the ball over, but his lack of effort to get back on defense. He should never have dropped his head. The only thought that should have entered his mind was ” I need to sprint as fast as I can down the court to stop the other team from scoring.
1.03 seconds – 1.11 seconds ( READ THEN WATCH THEN READ THEN WATCH )
Watch Jeremy Lin in this sequence after the ball is stolen by the 76ers. If you notice, Lin takes a completely wrong angle to cut off Iguodala’s coast-to-coast drive to the basket. If you STOP the video at exactly 1.09 seconds, you will see that Jeremy Lin should have raced down the court and got his body inside the key instead of above the free throw line. If he would have raced and squared his body inside the key, he would have, at minimum, forced Iguodala to alter his direction to the basket, making it more difficult to score.
1.15 seconds – 1.21 seconds ( READ THEN WATCH THEN READ THEN WATCH )
After starting the clip at 1.15, STOP it again at 1.16. You’ll see Jeremy Lin and #7 Carmelo Anthony trapping on the pic-n-roll. This leaves #21 for the 76ers open. Now, start the video again and STOP it at 1.17. You’ll then see that #21 for the 76ers gets the ball, and the player for the Knicks responsible for rotating on defense is #2 Landry Fields. In this situation, it is Fields job to pick up the ball and help Carmelo out, because Carmelo and Lin had trapped the point guard for the 76ers. Watch how #2 Landry Fields closes out on #21 and picks up the man with the ball. Instead of keeping his body between the ball and the basket, he cheats and jumps the passing lane when #21 fakes his pass. When #21 fakes his pass, he not only gets #2 Landry Fields to jump out of position, but also #6 Tyson Chandler. Both Fields and Chandler go for the pass fake instead of staying ” home “. So you not only have these two players jumping out of position on defense, you also see that Carmelo is slow to get back to help on defense after trapping the ball. Lastly, if you STOP the video at 1.18, you’ll see that #21 will drive to the basket. #21 Iman Shumpert for the Knicks is the last guy to help, but stays in his spot. What he should have done is slide over to help stop the dribbler by getting his body in front of the ball.
1.27 seconds – 1.34 seconds ( READ THEN WATCH THEN READ THEN WATCH )
In this sequence, the 76ers start a fastbreak and Amare Stoudemire runs down on defense, but fails to see the ball at all times. It almost appears he’s running down on defense without a true purpose in mind: to stop the opponent from scoring!! STOP the video at 1.31 and you’ll see the most fundamental error that a player can commit on defense: taking your eyes off the ball.
Defense, to me, is always the one element that separates a decent team from a great team. Defense is a choice. You either play it with all your heart, or you just go through the motions. This video clip demonstrates that defense, just like offense, is a team concept, and only works if everyone is doing their job.





